OHS home

Ohio Historical Society / The African American Experience in Ohio, 1850-1920






Item Description Next Next
Letter from Captain U.S. Army, Military Attache to Hon. Dr. Wm Crum, American Minister Resident, Rep. Liberia
American Legation,
Office of the Military Attache.

Monrovia, Liberia,
August 18, 1912.

Hon. Dr. Wm. D. Crum,
American Minister Resident,
Rep. Liberia.

Dear Sir:
     In response to your request for my opinion as to the proposed 
re-opening of the Franco-Liberian boundary question, I have the honor to 
thank you for the privilege and to make reply as follows:-
     I submit that Liberia can only lose by the proposed exchange, 
as it means giving up good and desirable country, fitted for homes 
and agriculture with its added prospects of mineral wealth, all situ-
ated in the famous Mandingo highlands, in return for a section of coun-
try without immediate productive or commercial possibilities.  Very lit-
tle of this high grass country remains to Liberia, her two aggressive 
neighbors on the north and east having filched by degrees the major 
portion away on some pretext or other, and all similar to the one now 
offered by France in this last proposal--that of uniting tribes who 
desire (as the French officials say) the protection of that government 
which seems to seek to clinch its proposal with a veiled threat of 
reclamation for damages as yet undetermined and ex-parte.
     I do not deny that Liberia may have to pay in the ultimate 
whenthese claims have been proprly presented and mutually adjusted 
by the representatives of both governments: for it can not be denied 
that many of her officials on these frontiers have been ignorant, 
dishonest and inefficient.  But I submit that these claims should be 
paid in money and not at the expense of alienating more of the ter-
ritory of Liberia, one third of which has already been lost to her thr 
thru the covetousness and superior strength of the adjoining natio
     Therefore I feel that Liberia should say no to these demands for 
the reason above mentioned and for the following additional ones:-
    1. The boundaries of Liberia along the large rivers of the fron-
tiers have been always fixed by her more powerful neighbors by their 
taking the whole of the river and allowing Liberia to navigate the 
river by sufferance only.  This has made it inconvenient and at times 
impossible to reach the frontier trade.  Liberia owes it no her sur-
vival to henceforth guard against the cession ofany more lands fit-
ted for agriculture and located on or near the principal trade routes 
of the interior or of thefrontier.
    2. The present boundary was in the main fixed by the French Col-
onial authorities in 1907, and seemed to suit them admirably.  Liberia 
yielded, tho she felt the arrangement was not an equitable one, in 
order to fix definitely and for all time thse limits.  When the treat-
y was concluded, she thought that with the putting in place of the 
permanent boundary marks that this would put an end to the difficul-
ties obtaining there in regard to metes and bounds.
	The spirit of this is embodied in the treaty of 1907, Liberia 
assuming with France at the same time the duty of policing this 
frontier line.  She allowed, in contributing to this end, the privilege 
to France of occupying posts upon Liberian soil until Liberia could 
get a force properly organized to do this policing alone.  It would 
seem, then, that anyindemnities claimed by French traders for tribal 
disturbances are not in justice chargeable to Liberia until she has 
stated her ability to cope with the situation unaided and has re-
quested the complete withdrawal of the French troops.
    3. Liberia feels (and justly so) that any expenses that France has 
been put to for quelling disturbances and maintaining peace between 
the trbes has already been fully and even re-paid by the hold upon 
Liberian lands let go and yielded to France in the treaty of 1907.
	She is at present organizing with all possible haste a trained 
forceto occupy the lines fixed by the last treaty, in order to relieve 
France of this duty under the agreement.

Download High Resolution TIFF Image
Item Description Next Next

Charles Young Collection

Letter from Captain U.S. Army, Military Attache to Hon. Dr. Wm Crum, American Minister Resident, Rep. Liberia


http://www.ohiohistory.org || Last modified
Ohio History Connection 800 E. 17th Ave. Columbus, OH 43211 © 1996-2011 All Rights Reserved.